My Photo

Raves

Tip Jar

Change is good

Tip Jar
Blog powered by Typepad

« Sustainable and Urban Gardening News January 2010 | Main | Allan Armitage—as you've never seen him before »

Comments

I thought the goal was to prevent flopping - right? So how come your super-tall ones don't? (Coz I agree the height looks nice.)

Height creates flopping--so stunting them prevents that. But I think the varieties I get from OHG are less likely to flop. So I probably never needed the gin.

I tried the gin this year, I must have put more in one of the vases, but I was still quite happy with the results. Mine were still tall enough, but didn't get floppy. It was strange getting the whiff of gin when I walked by at the beginning though :). Yours definitely got really stunted, I would not have enjoyed that.

You can also do this with rubbing alcohol--much cheaper.

If you want them to be a bit taller, but not tall enough to flop, just add a bit more water.

The flowers look lovely and I can smell their distinct scent all the way to S. Carolina.

Gin, hm ? Never heard that before. Now I know what to do with the bottle my brother-in-law left behind ( stuff tastes like turpentine to me ). Wonder if it'll work on amaryllis ?

I heard Vodka works, as well as pennies. I've tried putting pennies in a vase of Tulips, and they sure did stand up straight. Looked weird to me, but some people might like it.

Elizabeth, I agree your stunted bulbs don't look quite right -- but really, I think it's the vase they're planted in that's the source of the problem. The height of the vase isn't visually balanced with the short paperwhite stems. I think the bulbs would look stunning, however, planted in a low bowl or pot to balance out the arrangement.

I've done this the past two years with vodka and found it to be very successful in keeping the paperwhites to a smaller size. I didn't have your issue with stunting, but my bulbs aren't fancy - just grabbed out of the giant no-name bin at the nursery. Any alcohol works, as does rubbing alcohol but the proportions are different. I posted a photo showing the variation in height I got when I tried this for the first time in 2008:

http://tinyurl.com/yb4z7q3

This year I bought a small bottle of inexpensive vodka - in this economy, can't afford to be wasting the imported stuff on flowers.

I'm glad now I didn't try this this year -- I'm just growing regular old (stinky!) paperwhites, but they've been just the right height -- I think because I keep my house so cold to save on gas bills. Last time I grew them I was sharing a house with an extremely cold-sensitive room mate, and they were a floppy mess.

Interesting. I've never heard of growth stunting with alcohol. I mean in plants. Maybe less gin and you'll get an medium height narsissis? Oh experiment time!

For the past several years I've been running my own paperwhite/rubbing alcohols trials. What I've found is if you maintain the water at about 10% alcohol until the plant is about 6 or 8 inches tall, then flush with clear water, they continue to grow, but the stems stay firm and upright.

I might try just a drop of gin in the water. The ones I tried this year stayed remarkably upright, especially considering that they're in a Hyacinth vase. I don't believe in wasting vodka, even the cheap stuff.

Here's a Cornell paper on stunting tazettas with alcohol:

http://www.hort.cornell.edu/department/faculty/wmiller/bulb/Pickling_your_Paperwhites.pdf

(Thanks to OHG's archived newsletters for the link.)

The comments to this entry are closed.

And Now a Word From...

Garden Bloggers Fling

Dig It!

Find Garden Speakers At:

GardenRant Bookstore

Awards

Design

And...

AddThis Feed Button
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Your email address:


Powered by FeedBlitz

widget